NNEREN Talking Points January 15, 2014
* The Board observed a demonstration of NAR’s Realtor® Property Resource product. Veronica McManus and Ron France visited the Board and conducted the demo, after which the Board discussed issues pertaining to NNEREN possibly providing a comprehensive data feed to NAR for this purpose.
– As part of the Board’s discussions; thought was given to the long process previously undertaken when RPR last visited our Board to demo the RPR product as it existed at that time. Board members are aware that the review process conducted was performed over a two to three year period, and that review ultimately led to the decision of proceeding with competing products, rather than RPR. Obtaining revenue sharing to help keep our member’s dues low and obtaining the best public records available were both key elements during that process.
– The Board is also aware that there are existing contracts in place with other vendors that would have to be altered or cancelled in order to for us to legally be able to provide NNEREN data to RPR. This is because one of the uses of the data by RPR will be to re-purpose the data beyond the RPR interface and place the data in other products that RPR then will sell to third parties, such as bank and other lending institutions.
– A change in our current contracts would mean a reliable non-dues revenue source would be reduced and the cost of another product already available to our members now for free would then have a cost imposed on the MLS. Therefore, the impact on the budget is one of the issues that will need to be determined in detail before any decision on the matter is made. Consequently the Board has tasked the Executive Committee with determining the budget impact as well as all other options regarding this topic and to then report back to the full Board by April 9th.
– It was also noted that although there were some features unique to the RPR product, all the major features of RPR already exist in the MLS currently via InnoVia, Realist or Data Co-op. The CMA feature of RPR is particularly noteworthy however for being a very good CMA.
– It was further noted that the public records currently available to our members through Realist are judged by NNEREN staff review to be more comprehensive than the public records available in RPR. Our present deep integration of public records, which feature the ability to auto populate some listing maintenance fields with the current Realist product, is also considered an advantage over the RPR offering.
– A significant issue discussed was the situation in another MLS, where the MLS rescinded their data feed and contract from RPR after there was misuse of photo data by a third party data aggregator that RPR uses for data services. It was noteworthy also that after more than two years of providing a data feed to RPR from the that MLS, when the feed was eventually cut there was virtually no complaints from the membership since the product had garnered very little actual use by the membership of that MLS.
– The Board also notes that when the RPR product first became available, NNEREN took initiative and announced via system bulletins and monthly newsletters that an opt-in data feed from NNEREN has been made available to RPR featuring the ability of Brokers to opt-in to the feed via a setting in InnoVia. Despite the efforts to make Brokers aware of this fact by both NNEREN and State and local Associations, the results have been unimpressive, with only 5% of Brokers in NNEREN opting to send their listings to RPR.
– It was duly noted however that the RPR end user experience when first attempting to access RPR, where the MLS feed is not fully established, is not an encouraging experience because of certain messages and screen options built into the RPR settings. Thusly some who may have attempted to access RPR were likely dissuaded from pursuing access. The representatives from RPR were made aware again of the fact that improvements could and should be made to those RPR settings and programming to encourage more sign-ups.
– Regardless of the above mentioned practical issues, the Board acknowledges the political reality that many Realtors® understandably prefer to support an NAR product over a non-NAR vendor’s product. It was noted that some of our Shareholder Boards as well as the Vermont State Association (Vermont Realtors) have formally requested this MLS to participate in RPR by providing comprehensive MLS data.
– The Board and CEO take seriously the requests from our Shareholders and State Associations and fully understand such requests should carry great weight in this analysis as we complete our review and address this topic again in April.* The Board also reviewed a proposal from Supra lockbox systems which if adopted would initiate a replacement of the current lock boxes with Supra’s new blue tooth lock boxes featuring the ability to access the boxes with a cell phone and have no further need for an additional fob to be attached to the phone. The Executive Committee recommended going forward to negotiate a contract with Supra containing the terms as proposed.
– It was voted and passed that the Executive Committee (with input from legal counsel) is authorized to negotiate and have the CEO execute a new 6 year contract with Supra as outlined above.
* The Board was given a demonstration of the new and improved nneren.com website. In addition to an improved experience for members of the public, the member portal of the website will feature many improvements for members, including improved access to listing statistical data, quick links to training tools, and an updated version on online forms.
